facebook
rss
twitter
  • About
    • Contact
    • Elementary & Secondary Education Department
    • Social Concerns Department
  • Legislative Review
  • Issues
    • Catholic Education
    • Faith and Politics
    • Health Care
    • Life and Dignity
    • Marriage and Family
    • Religious Liberty
    • Social Justice
  • Bishops’ Statements
    • En Español
  • Resources
    • Bulletin Inserts
    • Church Documents
    • PA Catholic Statistics
    • Related Sites
    • Send A Letter to The Editor
  • Subscribe
    • RSS Feeds
    • Via E-mail
  • Contact
  • Podcast

A Case for School Choice

August 01, 2007
by Hill
Catholic Education Posts, catholic schools, education, educational improvement tax credit, EITC, school choice, taxes
Comments are off

This time of year there is a lot of talk about taxing and spending here in Harrisburg. The state legislature and the governor just agreed upon a $27.5 billion spending plan for the 2007-2008 budget, including $9.4 billion for education.

The Commonwealth Foundation for Public Policy Alternatives, a Harrisburg-based think tank, recently released a policy brief that is renewing the call for school choice. The Dollars and Sense of School Choice report supports several conclusions:

  • Per-pupil expenditures are substantially higher, and continue to rise more rapidly in traditional public schools than public charter, private, and home schools.

In the 2005-2006 school year, public school districts spend, on average, nearly $11, 500 per student. The average cost per student in Catholic schools is far less.

  • Alternative schools help relieve the strain on both state and local public education budgets and taxpayers.

If every student who attends a non-public school now returned to their traditional public school, it would cost the taxpayers an additional $3.073 billion.

  • The Educational Improvement Tax Credit (EITC) empowers parents to send their children to a school of choice, and does so while saving taxpayer money and leaving public schools better funded.

Since its inception, the EITC has given opportunities to thousands of families. Assuming a fair number of scholarship recipients would not have attended non-public schools without the assistance, the report concludes that for each dollar in EITC tax credits, public school districts save at least $1.89 in instructional costs alone.

  • School choice proposals such as the Property Tax Relief Scholarship Act would provide greater choices to parents, while providing property tax relief to homeowners for each student who migrates from a district school to a school of choice.

This legislative proposal would create a scholarship fund from which $3,000 scholarships would be made available to low income families to send their children to the school of their choice. Per-pupil expenditures far exceed the $3,000 allotment. The public school could return the difference to the taxpayers, providing property tax relief and taking some of the strain off the budget.

This proposal will be under consideration in the fall.

School choice is about more than the money. As the Commonwealth Foundation report says, “Educational choice gives parents the ability to choose the school that best meets their child’s needs, whether their goal is to remove their child from a failing or unsafe school or simply select an institution that better caters to their child’s specific educational needs.”

Catholic schools have provided parents with an excellent alternative to traditional public schools for generations. Catholic school students excel in math, reading and other skills. They go on to attend college at a very high rate and graduation levels are second to none. Many parents would love to send their children to Catholic schools, but because of economic constraints do not.

School choice makes sense. It’s time for Pennsylvania to reconsider this solution.

(486 words)

PCC Column August 2007 by Amy Beisel, Communications Director of the Pennsylvania Catholic Conference – the public affairs arm of Pennsylvania’s Catholic bishops and the Catholic dioceses of Pennsylvania.

Social Share
  • google-share

News From Around PA

  • Creators of ‘Bible in a Year’ podcast win national media award
  • National Seton shrine breaks ground on $4 million museum
  • Women’s voices: Pope says he’ll add women to Dicastery for Bishops
  • The Eucharistic Body of Christ—The Power for Evangelization
  • Custodian -- Saint Catherine Laboure Parish & St. Louise de Marillac School, Upper St. Clair
  • Diocese of Scranton Statement Regarding Monsignor Michael J. Delaney
Click To Read More

Post Archives

@·
now

Reply on Twitter Retweet on Twitter Like on Twitter Twitter

Recent Posts

This Week in PA Catholic Schools: 7-1-22
Jul 01, 2022
Our Series on Maternal & Early Childhood Issues: Breastfeeding - 9 stories
Jun 30, 2022
This Week in PA Catholic Schools: 6-24-22; Sports
Jun 24, 2022

All Issues

  • Catholic Education
  • Faith and Politics
  • Health Care
  • Life and Dignity
  • Marriage and Family
  • Religious Liberty
  • Social Justice

banner

Sign up to join the Catholic Advocacy Network today!

CClogo© 2021 Pennsylvania Catholic Conference. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons
Attribution Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 Unported License.
Bookmark and Share Site by Halibut Blue® | Login